Monday, September 10, 2007

Copyright and Fair Use SR

1. A student snaps in half a CD-ROM the teacher really needed for her next class. The teacher decides to make a back-up copy of all her crucial disks so it never happens again. This is permissible. TRUE. I was actually surprised by this case, although I agree that the teacher should be allowed to do this I was pleasantly surprised to discover that he is allowed to.

4. The state mandates technology proficiency for all high school students but adds no money to schools' software budgets. To ensure equity, public schools are allowed to buy what software they can afford and copy the rest. FALSE. I feel that in this particular circumstance that the schools were placed in a bad situation and that copying the rest would be in the best interest of the schools.

5. A geography teacher has more students and computers than software. He uses a CD burner to make several copies of a copyright interactive CD-ROM so each student can use an individual copy in class. This is fair use. FALSE. I believe that when you buy something that you have acquired the right to that particular thing and you should be allowed to do whatever you want with it. So in the case of the geography teacher since the CD-ROM was purchased I think that he should be allowed to copy it for the benefit of the class.

6. A middle school science class studying ocean ecosystems must gather material for multimedia projects. The teacher downloads pictures and information on marine life from various commercial and noncommercial sites to store in a folder for students to access. This is fair use. TRUE. I was a little bit surprised by this case because it did not say whether the teacher had to give credit to the sources in which he acquired the information from. I would assume that he must credit the sources and if that is the case than this does not surprise me at all.

8. A student film buff downloads a new release from a Taiwanese Web site to use for a humanities project. As long as the student gives credit to the sites from which he's downloaded material, this is covered under fair use. FALSE I feel that if the student gives credit to the sites that he downloaded it from that it should fall within the fair use guidelines. I understand the reasoning for it not being covered but I disagree.

10. A teacher gets clip art and music from popular file-sharing sites, then creates a lesson plan and posts it on the school Web site to share with other teachers. This is permissible. FALSE I am not surprised by the situation and the fact that it doesn't fall within the guidelines but I disagree with the fair use guidelines. I don't see the harm that sharing the lesson plan with other teachers does; you are just enhancing the education of the other teachers’ students.

12. A student tries to digitize the shower scene from a rented copy of Psycho into a "History of Horror" report. Her computer won't do it. The movie happens to be on an NBC station that week, so the teacher tapes it and then digitizes it on the computer for her. This is fair use. TRUE I actually was correct about this case but for the wrong reason, I didn't consider the blocking of the constitutional rights of the teacher to use materials for teaching. I thought that the reason for being able to use the NBC programs was that TV programs are public property.

14. On Back-to-School night, an elementary school offers child care for students' younger siblings. They put the kids in the library and show them Disney VHS tapes bought by the PTA. This is permissible. FALSE As I stated previously I feel that once you purchase something that you own the right to it so you should be allowed to do whatever you want with it. Again I don't see the harm in allowing the PTA to do this and actually find it rather comical that Disney will sell you a onetime license.

No comments: